Best Top Reviews Online

Retailer Shares Failure Rates for GPUs, Motherboards, SSDs, and Additional Components

Retailer data indicates which vendors are more trustworthy.

A retailer in the Philippines, Hardware Sugar (opens in a new tab), has shared the failure rates of the most popular hardware brands during its four years of operation. Although the sample size is small, it is intriguing to see which brands are returned most frequently. In addition to the relatively small sales area, it is important to note that other factors, such as user error, can influence this type of data. As such, consider it to be informational and not definitive.

The failure rate of graphics cards was the highest among all hardware components, particularly those manufactured by Gigabyte. The retailer’s RMA data revealed a 5% failure rate for graphics cards manufactured by Gigabyte. MSI graphics cards appeared to be more reliable, as only 1.5% of sold units failed. It is important to note that Hardware Sugar sold 9.3% more Gigabyte graphics cards than MSI graphics cards. Unfortunately, the retailer did not specify which models were more prone to failure. Additionally, it would have been interesting to determine whether Nvidia or AMD produces superior graphics cards.

Sold Failed Failure Rate
Graphics Cards
MSI 129 2 1.5%
Gigabyte 141 7 5%
MSI 470 10 2.4%
Gigabyte 388 7 1.8%
Power Supplies
Corsair 451 1 0.22%
DeepCool 46 0 0%
Cooler Master 157 3 2%
Seasonic 644 12 1.8
NZXT 154 6 4%
Corsair 42 0 0%
DeepCool 149 0 0%
G.Skill 601 4 0.66%
TeamGroup 179 2 1%
Samsung 257 0 0%
TeamGroup 243 3 1.2%

Regarding motherboards, the situation was reversed. MSI motherboards had a higher rate of failure (2.4% versus 1.8%) than Gigabyte motherboards. However, we are unable to determine whether Intel or AMD motherboards required the highest rate of RMAs.

The data also indicates that Seasonic power supplies are more popular in the Philippines than well-known brands such as Corsair and Cooler Master. Compared to Corsair, Hardware Sugar sold 42.8% more Seasonal units. However, Corsair was the most reliable brand overall, with a failure rate of less than one percent. Other vendors, such as Seasonic and Cooler Master, accounted for 1.8% and 2% of the market share, respectively.

Corsair and DeepCool cooling solutions, on the other hand, did not exhibit any failure at the time of the retailer’s video. However, the most popular NZXT cooling products had a 4% failure rate. We do not know whether this data pertains to air cooling, liquid cooling, or both. We suspect the latter because CPU air cooler failures are uncommon. A fan may occasionally fail prematurely, but it is uncommon for a heatsink to fail.

G.Skill was the preferred brand of memory among DIY users and consumers in the Philippines. Hardware Sugar sold 235.8% more G.Skill memory modules than TeamGroup memory modules. Despite the vast margin, G.Skill’s rate of failure was only 0.6%.

Samsung and TeamGroup were the most popular high-speed NVMe storage brands. The sales figures were comparable, but Samsung was the most reliable manufacturer with no RMAs. TeamGroup units, in contrast, had a 1.2% failure rate.

Why Trust Us?

Best Top Reviews Online was established in 2018 to provide our readers with detailed, truthful, and impartial advice on what to buy. We now have millions of monthly users from all over the world and annually evaluate over a thousand products.

The above article was written by the BestTopReviewsOnline team, which consists of some of the most knowledgeable technical experts in the United States. Our team consists of highly regarded writers with vast experience in smartphones, computer components, technology apps, security, and photography, among other fields.

Related Stories

  • All Post
  • Best Picks
  • Explainers
  • How To
  • News
  • Versus
MSI Z390 Motherboards Now Support 128GB RAM

January 6, 2019

MSI is the first manufacturer of motherboards to support 32GB DDR4 DIMMs on its Z390 motherboards. MSI Z390 motherboard owners can now utilize up to 128GB of memory with the help of a small BIOS update. Previously, it was only…

Get more info



Best Products

Buying Guides

Contact Us

About Us

We provide a platform for our customers to rate and review services and products, as well as the stores that sell them. We research and compare the most popular brands and models before narrowing it down to the top ten, providing you with the most comprehensive and reliable buying advice to help you make your decision.

Disclaimer is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Address & Map

20 S Santa Cruz Ave, Suite 300, Los Gatos, CA 95030, United States

© 2022 Pty. Ltd. All Rights Reserved. Licensing: All third-party trademarks, images, and copyrights used on this page are for comparative advertising, criticism, or review. As this is a public forum where users can express their opinions on specific products and businesses, the opinions expressed do not reflect those of